Inboxes are chaos. But the smartest teams don’t fight it; they run experiments inside it.

That’s exactly what Amnesty International USA and Blue State did. They turned their email program into a lab. 

Their goal wasn’t to send more messages; it was to learn faster, act on data, and make every message count.

In just nine months, that mindset powered 36 tests across fundraising, advocacy, and engagement, and drove a 21% increase in revenue year over year.

Amnesty USA’s experimentation engine
Each quarter, Amnesty and Blue State set two or three testing objectives tied to measurable goals like lifting average gift or increasing sustainer conversion. 

Then they designed experiments to answer those questions clearly. They tested:

  • Dynamic ask strings on donation forms

  • Advocacy layouts and CTAs

  • Segment-specific content and send strategies

One of the simplest wins came from emailing inactive subscribers. 

Instead of asking them to “Sign your name,” Amnesty USA tested a Yes/No question — a low-friction ask that dramatically boosted response rates from this colder audience.

On the giving side, they refined donation flows by adding lightbox gift upgrade prompts.

The results:

  • 21% overall revenue (Jan–Aug, year over year)

  • 12% higher average one-time gifts

  • 22% more sustainer gifts

Why it worked
Amnesty USA’s success shows that discipline beats volume. 

By setting clear quarterly priorities and designing tests with specific hypotheses, they avoided random optimization and built a feedback loop that compounded over time.

  • Testing with purpose: Every experiment connected to a goal, not just a hunch.

  • Audience-led insights: Different segments behave differently, so CTAs and ask logic were adjusted accordingly. 

  • Full-funnel lift: Smarter donation-form UX and sustainership prompts amplified email creative, turning clicks into long-term revenue.

How to apply the Amnesty USA/Blue State playbook to your program

✅ Set a quarterly testing roadmap. Choose 2–3 objectives (e.g., increase average gift, grow sustainers) and design tests that answer those questions.

✅ Design “inactive-friendly” CTAs. Use Yes/No or single-tap responses for colder audiences, and measure next-step conversion instead of just click rate.

✅ Optimize donation forms early. Test dynamic asks by segment, preselect monthly giving thoughtfully, and use a lightbox upgrade prompt to surface recurring options.

✅ Track your learning intentionally. Create a live dashboard and define decision rules before launch — so results drive action, not just slide decks.

✅ Protect your plan. Build a rapid-response checklist so urgent moments don’t derail your testing cadence.

The bottom line
There’s no magic subject line here, just a system.

Amnesty USA and Blue State proved that 36 focused tests in nine months can produce meaningful, sustained growth.

Your inbox can, too — when learning is the strategy, not the afterthought.

Industry events

Check our events list for more or reply to this email to submit one for consideration.

'Til next time!
Sara

P.S. Looking to add donors to your email list before year-end comes knocking? See how Civic Shout can help.

Keep reading

No posts found