How nonprofits can stay “most relevant” in Gmail

Have an email-related win you’d like us to feature? Reply to this email and let us know.

Nonprofit fundraisers have lived with Gmail’s Promotions tab long enough to know it cuts both ways.

It helps keep inboxes tidy for users — but it also means your urgent appeals show up alongside sneaker sales and flight deals.

This fall, Gmail is rewriting the rules of how those Promotions emails surface. 

The update introduces a “Most Relevant” view on mobile, where messages from senders people engage with most rise to the top.

A plain chronological “Most Recent” view is still available, but relevance will be the default for many users. Gmail will also layer on “nudges” that spotlight timely or urgent offers.

And that’s not all. Gmail is quietly adjusting other parts of its tabbed inbox:

Purchases tab. Transactional emails like receipts and shipping updates are being siphoned into their own lane.

For nonprofits, that means donation confirmations or ticket receipts should be kept squeaky clean: no cross-sells, upsells, or embedded appeals that make them look like marketing.

If it’s a critical service message, let it act like one.

Manage subscriptions expansion. As we covered last month, Gmail is making it easier for users to unsubscribe.

That’s good news for users, but a warning sign for senders: if people don’t find value in your content, they’ll prune you fast.

Why this matters
In practice, Gmail’s changes mean delivery doesn’t equal visibility. Two subscribers can open Gmail at the same time and see very different stacks of emails, depending on how often — and how quickly — they interact with a sender.

For nonprofits, inbox placement is no longer just about clearing the spam filter. It’s about earning relevance.

Practical steps for nonprofits
As always, intention matters when ensuring your supporters are seeing your emails:

1. Build interaction into every send
Whether it’s a donation link, a survey, or a petition, every message should have a clear reason to click.

2. Keep time-sensitive asks obvious
“Nudges” will reward urgency. Make deadlines, matches, and breaking news unmistakable — but they should also be genuine.

3. Segment transactional vs. promotional
Donation receipts, event confirmations, and membership renewals should stay stripped of marketing fluff. 

4. Write subject lines with clarity, not clutter
Test subject lines that tell supporters why your message matters now.

5. Expect faster list churn
With unsubscribes more prominent, nonprofits need to prioritize value: mix in cultivation emails, thank-yous, impact, and stories to keep supporters connected between appeals.

The bottom line
Gmail’s changes raise the bar for nonprofit emailers. The Promotions tab is no longer just about timing — it’s about trust, clarity, and consistent engagement.

Organizations that deliver relevant, timely, and valuable content won’t just survive these shifts. They’ll climb to the top of the stack.

Check our events list for more or reply to this email to submit one for consideration.

'Til next time!
Sara