One ophthalmologist at Sharp HealthCare in San Diego keeps a shelf in his office for the pins he’s received when grateful patients made gifts in his honor.

Those pins come with a deadline, and that deadline is the reason Sharp’s best Doctors’ Day email this spring worked.

Their approach is worth borrowing well beyond hospitals.

The breakthrough
Doctors’ Day falls on March 30. Through Sharp’s Guardian Angel program, grateful patients and families can make a gift in honor of a doctor who cared for them.

Sharp HealthCare, a San Diego health system, has several hospital foundations under one roof. Donors can honor a doctor through Sharp HealthCare Foundation, Grossmont Hospital Foundation, or Coronado Hospital Foundation.

In 2026, Sharp HealthCare Foundation ran Doctors’ Day for all three from one shared setup, with agency partner Doing Good Digital. 

Here’s what changed:

The deadline had real, tangible stakes. Donors who gave by March 15 had a commemorative pin sent to their doctor in time for Doctors’ Day.

The cutoff existed because the pins had to physically reach doctors by a certain time. Some asks came directly from a doctor. Emails 2 and 4 switched from a campaign-style design to a personal letter from a Sharp physician.

One template served three foundations. Every email came from the same shared template, with location-specific copy swapped in through conditional content.

The results
The campaign brought in 1,752 gifts, up from 1,272 the year before.

The campaign hit a 0.97% click-through rate and a 0.09% response rate, above the M+R Benchmarks average for fundraising email in 2025.

The physician letters drew nearly double the response of the campaign-style sends. 

Email 4, which was both a physician letter and the last push before the pin deadline, hit a 3.14% click-through rate and a 0.175% response rate, bringing in 110 gifts on its own.

An abandoned cart email went to everyone who didn’t complete a gift, minus suppressed contacts and anyone who had given to the campaign offline. 

It added 2% of total campaign revenue, more than Email 9 raised on its own.

How to apply this to your program
Find a thank-you moment your supporters already care about. Nurses Week and Teacher Appreciation Week work the same way Doctors’ Day does, because the gift honors someone the donor knows.

Make sure your deadline has real, tangible stakes. If a pin or a card has to reach someone by a certain date, build the campaign backward from that date and tell donors why it exists.

Obviously, year-end has tangible stakes for a tax write-off, so be sure to remind your donors!

Hand the pen to someone close to the work. A letter from a doctor or a caseworker reads differently than an email from the development team.

Set up an abandoned cart-style email for people who clicked and didn’t give. It’s a one-time build that pays off every campaign after, even as clicks have become an increasingly unreliable metric.

Some donation platforms have an abandoned cart email feature built-in, so check and make sure you’re using it!

The bottom line
Sharp’s Doctors’ Day campaign works because it gives grateful patients something they already want to do: thank the person who took care of them.

If your supporters have someone they’d want to thank, like a nurse or a volunteer, you probably have a campaign like this waiting to be built.

A great campaign only goes as far as your list. Over 1,000 causes, including Feeding America and Amnesty International, are growing their email lists with Civic Shout. See how you can too.

Industry events

Check our events list for more or reply to this email to submit one for consideration.

UNO Draw 25 meme. A hand holds an UNO card that reads "Give donors real stakes for your deadline OR draw 25." Next to it, a man sits at a table holding a thick fan of UNO cards, having chosen to draw 25 rather than follow the instruction.

‘Til next time!
Sara

Keep reading