Year-end email plans often run on habit, like resending an appeal unchanged or asking donors for at least what they gave last time.

December is the best time to put those habits to the test, with more emails going out than usual. 

The hard part is deciding which tests are worth running.

NextAfter’s experiment library is one of my favorite places to find those results and borrow ideas for my own tests.

Here are three tests from its archive worth running this December.

More than the match
A nonprofit tested two versions of a match email. 

The control led with a standard match appeal from the CEO.

The test offered the same match, but came from a mom the organization had helped, telling her family’s story in her own words.

The test drove 54% more people to give than the control, in a test of more than 500,000 people.

The read? Every December inbox is chock full of match offers. The match gave them a reason to give now, but the story gave them a reason to choose this organization.

Naming the streak
A nonprofit campaign split a list of donors who had given across multiple years.

The test version used the subject line “Don’t Break the Streak, [FirstName]!” In the body, it pointed out their history of giving and asked them to keep it going.

Conversions rose from 0.49% to 0.80% on a sample of more than 48,000, and clicks rose 81%.

The read? December is when loyal donors either renew or quietly skip a year. Naming the streak makes that choice visible.

This kind of message likely wears off with overuse, so I’d save it for critical moments… like year-end.

Asking for less than last time
During a fiscal year-end campaign in 2022, a nonprofit tested asking donors for less than their previous gift.

The email named what each donor had given before and said that, with inflation and high prices, it wasn’t asking for the same level of support.

Conversion rose from 0.09% to 0.15% on a sample of more than 1.7 million. The average gift came in 4% higher.

The read? RKD Group found the average gift is down 13% since 2017 after inflation, so a lower ask might sound like the wrong direction.

But acknowledging what donors are dealing with brought in more gifts here, and those gifts didn’t get smaller.

How to apply these learnings to your program
Give your match emails a story. Test your standard match appeal against one that pairs the match with a single story, sent by someone other than your CEO.

Pull your consecutive-year donors now. Anyone who has given in each of the last few years is a candidate for a streak message before December 31.

Try a lower ask on one segment. Lapsed donors feel like a perfect cohort for this approach.

Test an ask below their last gift with a line that explains why, and track average gift alongside response.

The bottom line
All three tests changed how an email spoke to people who already knew the organization. 

None of them needed a redesign or a new tool.

Pick one, and you’ll have interesting data to use for future content in 2027!

The bigger your list, the faster your tests tell you something. Learn how over 1,000 causes, including Amnesty International and Feeding America, grow their email lists with Civic Shout.

Industry events

Check our events list for more or reply to this email to submit one for consideration.

Quick hits

Spider-Man pointing meme: two identical Spider-Men point at each other in front of a police van. The caption reads, “Every Giving Tuesday subject line this year.”

‘Til next time!
Sara

Keep reading